The Allure of Morally Ambiguous Characters in Dark Urban Fantasy

The Allure of Morally Ambiguous Characters in Dark Urban Fantasy

By Neal Martin/ April 1, 2023
Last Updated May 7, 2023
morally ambiguous character

Character complexity is a crucial element in storytelling, capturing the interest of readers and audiences alike. One particularly appealing aspect of this complexity is the presence of morally ambiguous characters, especially in the world of dark urban fantasy.

In this article, we will delve into the definition and characteristics of morally ambiguous characters, the rise of dark urban fantasy, and the role these characters play in the genre. Additionally, we will discuss notable examples from literature and adaptations in television and film, as well as the appeal of such characters for both writers and readers.

Defining Morally Ambiguous Characters

morally ambiguous characters

Moral ambiguity, a deliciously complex and fascinating aspect of character development, keeps readers on their toes as they navigate the intricate landscape of ethics and intentions. Take a stroll through the morally murky waters, and you’ll find that the appeal of morally ambiguous characters lies in their unpredictability, their captivating internal struggles, and the way they challenge our preconceived notions of right and wrong. They’re like the jalapeños in your nachos, keeping things spicy, unpredictable, and endlessly entertaining.

For instance, imagine a hero who, on one hand, saves the world from supernatural threats but, on the other, isn’t above manipulating a few innocent souls to get the job done (looking at you, John Constantine!). Picture a protagonist who fights for justice but will engage in morally ambiguous actions to do so, leaving readers wondering whether the ends truly justify the means (Ethan Drake, is that you?). These are the type of characters that captivate us, that entertain us, and make us question our own moral compass.

Let’s dive deeper into the realm of moral ambiguity with some colorful examples. In HBO’s “Game of Thrones,” we have Tyrion Lannister, a character whose wit, charm, and cunning actions make it difficult for viewers to decide if he’s a hero, a villain, or something in between. He’s a master of manipulation and plays the game of thrones with expert precision. Still, he also has moments of genuine compassion and empathy, making his moral standing all the more captivating.

In the world of comics, Marvel’s Deadpool is a prime example of moral ambiguity. As a wise-cracking, fourth-wall-breaking anti-hero, Deadpool does not hesitate to use violence and questionable methods to achieve his goals. However, his twisted sense of humor and tragic backstory make it difficult to label him as purely villainous. Deadpool’s morally ambiguous nature keeps readers entertained and intrigued, as they never quite know what to expect from the “Merc with a Mouth.”

When it comes to morally ambiguous characters, it’s not just about their actions but also their motivations. A character might commit heinous acts, but if their reasons for doing so are grounded in a desire to protect loved ones or exact justice, does that make them evil? It’s these thought-provoking questions that add depth and complexity to morally ambiguous characters, making them an essential ingredient in creating compelling, entertaining stories.

Morally ambiguous characters bring a sense of excitement, uncertainty, and complexity to storytelling. Their actions and motivations keep readers guessing and questioning their own moral beliefs, making for a truly captivating and entertaining experience. Whether they are anti-heroes, conflicted protagonists, or sympathetic villains, morally ambiguous characters will continue to enthrall audiences and challenge the boundaries of conventional storytelling.

The Rise of Dark Urban Fantasy

urban fantasy tropes

Dark urban fantasy is a subgenre that combines elements of urban fantasy with darker, more mature themes. It often features supernatural creatures, magic, and morally ambiguous characters existing in gritty, contemporary settings. This genre has evolved over time, with notable works such as Neil Gaiman’s “Neverwhere” and Laurell K. Hamilton’s “Anita Blake: Vampire Hunter” series paving the way for its growing popularity. Readers have become increasingly captivated by the genre’s blend of fantasy and reality, as well as its ability to explore complex themes and character development.

I won’t go into detail here about the dark urban fantasy genre because I’ve already done so in these articles:

Unveiling the Shadows: A comprehensive Guide to Dark Urban Fantasy

Navigating the World of Urban Fantasy: Tropes and Cliches to Watch For

The Role of Morally Ambiguous Characters in Dark Urban Fantasy

urban fantasy character

In the shadowy realm of dark urban fantasy, morally ambiguous characters reign supreme, entwining readers in a web of intrigue, power struggles, and existential quandaries. These characters not only grapple with supernatural beings and arcane forces, but also wrestle with their own murky moral compass, embarking on a thrilling journey that keeps readers turning the pages.

Delving into the heart of darkness, morally ambiguous characters confront challenging themes such as the nature of good and evil, the corrupting influence of power, and the instinct for survival. Imagine a protagonist who toes the line between savior and destroyer, making deals with demons or using dark magic to vanquish their foes. The very actions that protect their city from supernatural threats may simultaneously erode their own humanity, leaving readers to ponder the true cost of victory.

Morally ambiguous characters in dark urban fantasy offer a tantalizing exploration of the human condition, as their experiences mirror the moral dilemmas we face in our own lives. By incorporating these complex figures into their narratives, authors craft stories that not only entertain but also challenge readers to confront their own ethical boundaries.

These gray characters are the beating heart of dark urban fantasy, injecting an irresistible blend of excitement, depth, and complexity into the genre. Their battles with supernatural forces and their own inner demons provide readers with thought-provoking, engaging experiences that linger long after the final page is turned.

Notable Morally Ambiguous Characters in Dark Urban Fantasy Literature

ethan drake series urban fantasy

Some iconic morally ambiguous characters in dark urban fantasy literature include:

    1. Harry Dresden (The Dresden Files by Jim Butcher): This wizard-slash-private investigator, Dresden, juggles fireballs and detective work like it’s no big deal. But when it comes to making moral choices, he’s as clumsy as a newborn giraffe on roller skates. Sure, he’s got a heart of gold beneath his snarky exterior, but Dresden’s decisions often revolve around survival and protecting his loved ones, rather than sticking to a rigid moral code. As a result, we’re left wondering whether he’s a hero, a mess, or simply a magical tornado in a trench coat.
    2. Mercy Thompson (Mercy Thompson series by Patricia Briggs): A shapeshifting mechanic who can turn into a coyote? Now that’s a protagonist you can’t help but love. Mercy Thompson, however, is no goody two-shoes. She might be courageous and fiercely loyal to her friends, but when push comes to supernatural shove, she’s not above bending the rules or getting her paws dirty. Her morally ambiguous choices keep readers on the edge of their seats, pondering whether this coyote’s tricks are for the greater good or just clever survival instincts.
    3. October “Toby” Daye (October Daye series by Seanan McGuire): Half-human, half-fae, and 100% morally perplexing, October “Toby” Daye is a knight and a private investigator who navigates the treacherous waters of the fae world. While her intentions are good, Toby’s actions can sometimes fall into the morally grey zone. Whether it’s making deals with the less-than-savory inhabitants of Faerie or skirting the edge of fae laws, Toby’s morally ambiguous decisions make readers wonder if she’s truly the knight in shining armor we hope for, or if she’s just another fae playing the long game.
    4. Atticus O’Sullivan (Iron Druid Chronicles by Kevin Hearne): If you’ve ever wondered what a 2,000-year-old Druid would look like in modern times, look no further than Atticus O’Sullivan. With a snarky sense of humor and a knack for getting into supernatural trouble, Atticus knows his way around the arcane arts. But when it comes to morality, he’s as slippery as a well-oiled weasel. Atticus tends to act in his own best interests, often using his magical abilities for personal gain or manipulating both mortal and immortal beings to achieve his goals. His morally ambiguous nature keeps readers entertained and guessing, as they try to unravel the enigma of this ancient druid in a world of smartphones and fast food.
    5. John Constantine (Hellblazer series): Picture a chain-smoking, trench coat-wearing, British conman with a penchant for the occult, and you’ve got John Constantine. He’s got the swagger of a rock star and the morals of a back-alley poker game. While he occasionally finds himself fighting on the side of angels, Constantine’s not afraid to cut deals with demons when it suits him. His morally ambiguous actions keep us guessing whether he’s in it for the greater good, or just playing both sides for his own benefit. Whatever his motives, this street-smart sorcerer always keeps us entertained with his cheeky wit and devil-may-care attitude.
    6. Sandman Slim (Sandman Slim series by Richard Kadrey): James “Sandman Slim” Stark is your classic hard-boiled anti-hero, with a supernatural twist. After escaping from Hell, literally, he’s got a chip on his shoulder the size of a demonic boulder. Sandman Slim’s moral compass seems to point directly at revenge and self-interest, but every now and then, he surprises us by doing something almost heroic. With his snarky one-liners, penchant for destruction, and morally ambiguous choices, Sandman Slim keeps us laughing, cringing, and wondering what he’ll do next.
    7. Ethan Drake (Ethan Drake/Infernal Justice series by N.P. Martin): If you thought having a demonic alter ego was bad, try living with a demon partner, six Hellbastards, and a Hellicorn. That’s the daily reality for demon hunter and supernatural investigator Ethan Drake. This morally ambiguous character often walks a tightrope between protecting humanity from supernatural threats and resorting to ethically questionable methods to achieve his goals. As Drake battles external enemies and his own internal demons (pun intended), we can’t help but chuckle at his dark humor and wonder whether he’ll eventually tip the scales towards good or be consumed by the darkness within.

The Appeal of Morally Ambiguous Characters for Writers and Readers

urban fantasy tropes

Morally ambiguous characters are the secret sauce that gives dark urban fantasy its irresistible flavor. For writers, these characters present a tantalizing opportunity to explore the shadowy corners of human nature, allowing them to craft stories that delve into the murky depths of morality and the consequences of one’s actions. Crafting morally grey characters can also challenge the cookie-cutter molds of conventional heroes and villains, giving writers the creative freedom to whip up a deliciously twisted narrative.

For readers, morally ambiguous characters offer a thrilling roller-coaster ride through the labyrinth of the human psyche. These characters force readers to question their own beliefs about morality and justice, often prompting them to reevaluate their assumptions about right and wrong, all while keeping them entertained with witty banter and supernatural shenanigans. Imagine a character who can crack a joke while battling demons or juggle ethical dilemmas with the same finesse as their enchanted weapons. That’s the kind of delightful chaos you’ll find in dark urban fantasy.

By engaging with morally ambiguous characters, readers can gain a deeper understanding of human nature, empathy, and the importance of considering multiple perspectives. Moreover, these characters keep readers on their toes, as they never know whether their favorite protagonist will make a noble sacrifice or strike a deal with the devil. This unpredictability keeps readers hooked, laughing, and eagerly turning the pages to find out what happens next.

In conclusion, morally ambiguous characters are the lifeblood of dark urban fantasy, infusing the genre with complexity, humor, and a healthy dose of moral uncertainty. For writers and readers alike, these characters offer an entertaining and thought-provoking exploration of the complexities of the human experience, challenging conventional notions of right and wrong while keeping us thoroughly entertained.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


red village ethan drake book 10
urban fantasy book cover design