10 Multi-Season Urban Fantasy TV Shows to Binge-Watch Right Now

10 Multi-Season Urban Fantasy TV Shows to Binge-Watch Right Now

By Neal Martin/ May 2, 2023
Last Updated May 2, 2023
urban fantasy tv shows

Calling all fans of the dark, the dangerous, and the downright magical! Urban fantasy television series are the ultimate guilty pleasure, offering viewers a tantalizing taste of the supernatural, served with a side of humor, angst, and lovably flawed characters.

Need a new show to sink your teeth into? Look no further! We’ve compiled a list of ten addictive urban fantasy series (made when TV shows went on for years and weren’t cancelled after one season – looking at you, Netflix) that’ll have you binge-watching like a vampire on a blood bank break-in.

1. Supernatural

urban fantasy tv shows

Join the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean, as they hit the road in their ’67 Chevy Impala, traversing the darker corners of America to hunt down all manner of ghosts, demons, and monsters. Supernatural has become a cult favorite for fans, and it’s easy to see why. With fifteen seasons of eerie encounters, snappy one-liners, and heart-wrenching brotherly drama, this show hooks viewers with a winning combination of relentless action, dark humor, and emotional depth.

One of the key reasons Supernatural is so binge-worthy is its unique blend of episodic “monster of the week” format with overarching storylines that delve into mythology, family dynamics, and the nature of good and evil. For example, the first season sees the brothers searching for their missing father while battling vengeful spirits, shapeshifters, and wendigos. Later seasons introduce angels, demons, and even God, weaving intricate tales that keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

Moreover, the show excels in character development, making Sam and Dean Winchester (played by Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles) two of the most beloved characters in urban fantasy television. Their unwavering bond and willingness to sacrifice for each other provide a powerful emotional core that resonates with fans. Supporting characters like the trench coat-wearing angel Castiel (Misha Collins) and the snarky demon Crowley (Mark Sheppard) add depth and complexity to the series.

Furthermore, Supernatural doesn’t shy away from exploring the consequences of the brothers’ actions and the weight of their choices. Episodes like “Mystery Spot” and “The French Mistake” showcase the show’s ability to balance high-stakes drama with meta-humor and self-awareness, acknowledging its own tropes and poking fun at the genre.

2. The Vampire Diaries

urban fantasy tv shows

Bloodthirsty for some drama? Immerse yourself in the mysterious small town of Mystic Falls, where vampires, werewolves, witches, and more secretly coexist with humans. The Vampire Diaries delivers eight intoxicating seasons of plot twists, brooding bloodsuckers, and tormented love stories that will have you spellbound. It’s like a fine wine spiked with blood and supernatural power struggles, making it the perfect binge-worthy series for fans of urban fantasy.

One reason The Vampire Diaries is so irresistible is its intricate narrative, which masterfully weaves together multiple storylines and characters, creating a rich tapestry of romance, suspense, and supernatural intrigue. For example, the central love triangle between Elena Gilbert (Nina Dobrev) and the vampire brothers Stefan (Paul Wesley) and Damon Salvatore (Ian Somerhalder) drives much of the show’s emotional tension, while supernatural threats like the Original vampires and the Travelers keep Mystic Falls perpetually on the brink of disaster.

The show’s ensemble cast is another key element in its binge-worthy appeal. In addition to the core characters, The Vampire Diaries introduces a slew of memorable supporting figures, including the sassy witch Bonnie Bennett (Kat Graham), the lovable werewolf Tyler Lockwood (Michael Trevino), and the resourceful human Matt Donovan (Zach Roerig). These characters, along with many others, add depth and complexity to the story, providing new angles and dimensions to explore.

Furthermore, The Vampire Diaries excels in its exploration of moral ambiguity, posing thought-provoking questions about the nature of good and evil, redemption, and the consequences of one’s actions. For instance, Damon’s journey from villain to anti-hero forces viewers to confront the idea that even the most monstrous individuals can change and find redemption, while Stefan’s struggle with his darker instincts reminds us that no one is entirely free from the shadows.

Finally, the show’s knack for crafting suspenseful, jaw-dropping cliffhangers ensures that viewers will be eager to dive into the next episode. Whether it’s the revelation of a hidden connection between characters, the introduction of a new supernatural threat, or a shocking betrayal, The Vampire Diaries consistently keeps fans on their toes, making it the perfect series to binge.

3. Teen Wolf

urban fantasy tv shows

Who knew the werewolf life could be so… teen angsty? Teen Wolf, an inventive reimagining of the werewolf mythos, follows Scott McCall (Tyler Posey) as he juggles high school, first love, and the occasional lacrosse game, all while battling supernatural baddies with his loyal pack. With six seasons of suspense, wit, and wolfish horror, this clever teen fantasy drama explores the challenges of being “other” and making tough choices in a world where sometimes, the monsters are the ones you least expect.

One aspect that makes Teen Wolf so binge-worthy is its ability to seamlessly blend supernatural elements with relatable coming-of-age themes. The show explores the trials and tribulations of adolescence, such as navigating friendships, discovering one’s identity, and finding love, all within the context of a fantastical universe. For example, Scott’s burgeoning romance with the enigmatic Allison (Crystal Reed) is both tender and fraught with danger, as he struggles to protect her from the supernatural world he’s inadvertently drawn her into.

Additionally, Teen Wolf is anchored by a diverse and dynamic ensemble cast, which contributes to its binge-worthy appeal. Characters like the sarcastic, quick-witted Stiles Stilinski (Dylan O’Brien) and the fierce, loyal werewolf Derek Hale (Tyler Hoechlin) provide depth and nuance to the show, while the evolving relationships between the various members of the pack create a rich tapestry of loyalty, trust, and camaraderie.

The show also excels in its exploration of the concept of “otherness” and the struggle for acceptance. Scott’s journey from social outcast to respected alpha werewolf serves as a metaphor for the challenges faced by those who feel different or marginalized. In this context, the supernatural creatures in Teen Wolf can be seen as allegories for real-life experiences of alienation, prejudice, and the search for belonging.

Moreover, Teen Wolf is known for its suspenseful, action-packed storytelling, which keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. From the introduction of dangerous supernatural creatures like the kanima and the dread doctors to the ever-shifting alliances and rivalries between various factions, the show constantly keeps fans guessing, making it impossible to resist the temptation to binge.

4. Grimm

urban fantasy tv shows

Ever wondered what would happen if those creepy Grimm Brothers’ fairy tales came to life? Look no further than Grimm, a dark and captivating series that follows homicide detective Nick Burkhardt (David Giuntoli) as he hunts down dangerous Wesen creatures while keeping his secret identity as a Grimm under wraps. Lasting six fantastical seasons, Grimm expertly blends a thrilling procedural premise with morally complex storytelling and eccentric characters caught between their human and beastly natures.

One of the key reasons Grimm is so binge-worthy is its unique premise that reimagines classic fairy tales within a modern urban setting. The show weaves together crime-solving and supernatural elements, as each episode features a new Wesen creature inspired by a Grimm fairy tale. For instance, the sinister hexenbiests and the ferocious blutbaden are inspired by the witches and the big bad wolves of the original tales, bringing familiar stories to life with a fresh and eerie twist.

Furthermore, Grimm delves into the moral complexities of its characters, as they struggle with their dual human and Wesen identities. The show explores themes of loyalty, love, and the tension between one’s nature and personal choices. For example, Monroe (Silas Weir Mitchell), a reformed blutbad, provides a fascinating portrayal of a Wesen trying to suppress his violent instincts and live a peaceful, human life. His unlikely friendship with Nick serves as a testament to the power of empathy and understanding, even in the face of ancient prejudices.

The show also excels in creating a rich mythology and a vibrant, diverse cast of characters. Supporting figures like Rosalee (Bree Turner), a Fuchsbau with a checkered past, and Hank (Russell Hornsby), Nick’s loyal human partner, add depth and nuance to the series. Moreover, the show delves into the history and politics of the Wesen world, with rival factions and royal families vying for power, making for an engrossing, multi-layered narrative.

Grimm’s ability to balance episodic storytelling with overarching plotlines keeps viewers hooked from one episode to the next. Fans are drawn in by the show’s clever twists on familiar tales and stay for the exploration of darker themes, such as the battle between humanity and one’s baser instincts, or the repercussions of unbridled power.

5. Buffy the Vampire Slayer

urban fantasy tv shows

Before there were sparkling vampires and werewolf love triangles, there was Buffy Summers – the original teenage vampire slayer who took the world (and the underworld) by storm. Over seven kickass seasons, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, created by the visionary Joss Whedon, mixed sharp dialogue, dark humor, and heartrending character arcs with high-stakes demon-slaying action. Buffy (played by Sarah Michelle Gellar) proved that even the smallest girl could have the biggest impact, making her a feminist icon and a trailblazer for urban fantasy heroines everywhere.

One of the aspects that makes Buffy the Vampire Slayer so binge-worthy is its groundbreaking approach to storytelling. The show expertly balances episodic “monster of the week” plots with season-long story arcs, keeping viewers invested in both the immediate threats and the larger narrative. For example, season two’s introduction of Angel’s (David Boreanaz) darker alter ego, Angelus, adds depth to Buffy’s character and creates a heart-wrenching conflict that spans multiple episodes.

Buffy also explores complex and relatable themes, such as the struggles of growing up, the search for identity, and the burden of responsibility. The show is unafraid to tackle darker topics, like grief, addiction, and loss, all while maintaining its trademark wit and humor. For instance, the episode “The Body” masterfully portrays the raw emotions and shock experienced by the characters after the death of a loved one, solidifying its status as a standout hour of television.

The show’s ensemble cast is another key factor in its binge-worthyb appeal. Buffy is surrounded by a diverse group of friends and allies, known as the Scooby Gang, each with their own unique personalities and storylines. Characters like the brilliant but shy Willow (Alyson Hannigan), the wise-cracking Xander (Nicholas Brendon), and the enigmatic Watcher, Giles (Anthony Stewart Head), provide humor, support, and depth to Buffy’s journey.

Moreover, Buffy the Vampire Slayer is known for its memorable and complex villains, who often serve as reflections or foils for the protagonist. From the charismatic Spike (James Marsters) to the diabolical Glory (Clare Kramer), these antagonists keep the stakes high and the battles fierce, while also challenging Buffy’s convictions and beliefs.

Finally, the show’s feminist themes and emphasis on female empowerment set it apart from other urban fantasy series. Buffy is a powerful, resourceful, and flawed heroine who inspires viewers with her resilience and determination. She consistently defies expectations and proves that strength comes in many forms.

6. Sleepy Hollow

urban fantasy tv shows

Have you ever wondered what would happen if Ichabod Crane, the protagonist of Washington Irving’s classic tale “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” suddenly found himself in the 21st century? Look no further than Sleepy Hollow, a captivating series that reimagines the iconic story with a modern twist. Over four thrilling seasons, the show expertly blends supernatural intrigue, historical elements, and a touch of humor, making it a perfect binge-worthy addition to the urban fantasy genre.

In this inventive series, Ichabod Crane (Tom Mison) is resurrected in present-day Sleepy Hollow, only to discover that his old nemesis, the Headless Horseman, has returned as well. Teaming up with tenacious police lieutenant Abbie Mills (Nicole Beharie), Crane is thrust into a battle against the forces of darkness, as they strive to unravel a mysterious conspiracy that spans centuries. Together, they form an unlikely partnership, using their combined knowledge of history and modern crime-solving techniques to protect the town and its residents from supernatural threats.

One of the aspects that makes Sleepy Hollow so binge-worthy is its ability to meld the fantastical with the historical. The show delves into early American history, with Crane’s past as a Revolutionary War spy and his connections to historical figures like George Washington and Benjamin Franklin. These glimpses into the past provide context for the supernatural events unfolding in the present, creating a rich and immersive narrative.

Additionally, the series boasts a diverse and dynamic cast of characters, with the chemistry between Crane and Mills serving as the heart of the show. The pair’s witty banter and evolving friendship provide levity amidst the darker, supernatural elements. Supporting characters like the enigmatic Captain Frank Irving (Orlando Jones) and the resourceful Jenny Mills (Lyndie Greenwood) further contribute to the show’s rich tapestry of personalities.

Sleepy Hollow also excels in its world-building, crafting a mythology that is both fascinating and intricate. From the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse to the shadowy organization known as the Freemasons, the show weaves together various mythologies, legends, and historical events to create an engrossing supernatural universe.

Moreover, the series features a host of terrifying and memorable villains, including the iconic Headless Horseman, who adds a sense of dread and urgency to Crane and Mills’ mission. Each season introduces new adversaries and challenges, ensuring that viewers remain on the edge of their seats.

7. Lucifer

urban fantasy tv shows

What happens when the Devil himself grows tired of ruling Hell and decides to take a vacation on Earth? You get the tantalizing and addictive urban fantasy series, Lucifer. Over six sinfully entertaining seasons, Lucifer blends supernatural intrigue, humor, and a dash of romance, making it an irresistible binge-worthy choice for fans of the genre.

The show revolves around the charismatic Lucifer Morningstar (Tom Ellis), the Devil himself, who trades the fiery depths of Hell for the glitz and glamour of Los Angeles. Opening a high-end nightclub called Lux, Lucifer’s life takes a turn when he becomes involved in a murder investigation and forms an unlikely partnership with no-nonsense LAPD detective Chloe Decker (Lauren German). Together, they solve crimes while exploring themes of redemption, forgiveness, and the complexities of human nature.

One of the key reasons Lucifer is so binge-worthy is its unique premise. The show offers a fresh take on the Devil, presenting him as a charming, quick-witted, and surprisingly sympathetic character. Tom Ellis’ captivating portrayal of Lucifer, complete with impeccable comic timing and an irresistible charm, is sure to make viewers question their preconceptions about the Prince of Darkness.

Furthermore, the series excels in its character development. The evolving relationship between Lucifer and Chloe is a central aspect of the show, with their undeniable chemistry and emotional connection driving much of the drama. Additionally, the series boasts a diverse ensemble cast, including the no-nonsense demon Mazikeen (Lesley-Ann Brandt), the conflicted angel Amenadiel (D.B. Woodside), and the lovable forensic scientist Ella Lopez (Aimee Garcia). Each character is well-developed and brings depth and nuance to the series.

Lucifer also benefits from its clever mix of procedural crime-solving and supernatural elements. Each episode features a new case for the duo to crack, while the overarching narrative explores Lucifer’s journey of self-discovery and redemption. The show weaves in various mythologies and biblical references, creating a rich tapestry that keeps viewers engaged and invested in the characters’ fates.

Moreover, the series does not shy away from tackling deeper themes and issues, such as morality, free will, and the consequences of one’s actions. Lucifer’s struggle to reconcile his devilish nature with his newfound humanity leads to some thought-provoking and emotionally resonant moments, adding further depth to the show.

8. True Blood

urban fantasy tv shows

In a world where vampires have “come out of the coffin” and live openly among humans, telepathic waitress Sookie Stackhouse (played by Anna Paquin) must navigate the perilous world of supernatural politics and steamy romance. With seven seductive seasons, True Blood delivers a heady mix of blood-soaked mystery, sizzling passion, and a distinctly Southern Gothic atmosphere. Prepare to have your heart racing and your skin crawling as you enter the sultry world of Bon Temps, Louisiana.

One of the key reasons True Blood is so binge-worthy lies in its unique premise. Based on Charlaine Harris’ “The Southern Vampire Mysteries” book series, the show imagines a world where the invention of synthetic blood allows vampires to reveal their existence to humans. This groundbreaking concept sets the stage for a rich exploration of societal issues, such as prejudice, tolerance, and the struggle for equal rights, cleverly intertwined with supernatural elements.

The series excels in its world-building, as it introduces viewers to a wide array of supernatural creatures, including werewolves, shapeshifters, and fairies, each with their own rules and customs. This diverse supernatural ecosystem adds depth and intrigue to the narrative, ensuring that each season presents new challenges and mysteries for Sookie and her companions.

True Blood is also known for its complex and multi-layered characters. The relationship between Sookie and vampire Bill Compton (Stephen Moyer) serves as the initial driving force of the series, with their passionate and tumultuous romance captivating viewers. Other characters, such as the enigmatic vampire Eric Northman (Alexander Skarsgård) and Sookie’s fiercely loyal brother Jason (Ryan Kwanten), add further depth to the story, providing both humor and heart to the series.

The show’s distinctly Southern Gothic atmosphere is another standout feature that adds to its binge-worthy appeal. The town of Bon Temps, with its Spanish moss-draped trees, sultry nights, and small-town secrets, provides a perfect backdrop for the series’ supernatural escapades. The show’s exploration of Southern culture and its blend of horror, mystery, and dark humor make for a uniquely immersive viewing experience.

Moreover, True Blood is renowned for its unapologetically adult themes, delivering steamy, passionate scenes alongside its supernatural intrigue. The show’s exploration of sexuality, desire, and the darker side of human nature adds an additional layer of seduction to the narrative, making it a guilty pleasure for many viewers.

9. Lost Girl

urban fantasy tv shows

Meet Bo (played by Anna Silk), a succubus who feeds on sexual energy to survive, as she grapples with her identity, power, and moral compass amidst a backdrop of supernatural conflict and complex relationships. With five electrifying seasons, Lost Girl showcases kickass heroines and an enthralling underworld populated by the enigmatic Fae. This Canadian urban fantasy series is a must-watch for fans who crave strong, empowering characters and a touch of seductive danger.

Lost Girl’s unique premise is one of the key factors that make it a binge-worthy urban fantasy series. Unlike traditional shows that often focus on vampires or werewolves, Lost Girl introduces viewers to the Fae, a mysterious group of supernatural beings with various powers and abilities. This fresh take on the urban fantasy genre keeps audiences captivated and intrigued, as each episode unveils new creatures and explores their rich lore and customs.

Another standout aspect of Lost Girl is its strong and diverse cast of characters. Bo’s journey of self-discovery takes center stage, as she learns to control her powers and navigates the complex world of the Fae. Alongside Bo is her fiercely loyal human sidekick Kenzi (Ksenia Solo), who adds a dose of humor and heart to the series. Their deep bond and unwavering friendship serve as the emotional core of the show.

Lost Girl is also lauded for its positive representation of LGBTQ+ relationships, breaking barriers within the genre. Bo’s bisexuality is treated as a natural and integral part of her character, and her relationships with both male and female partners are explored with sensitivity and depth. The show’s progressive portrayal of sexuality and relationships adds a refreshing and much-needed dimension to the urban fantasy landscape.

The series’ overarching narrative is another enticing element that keeps viewers hooked. As Bo uncovers the truth about her past and her place within the Fae world, she must also navigate the delicate balance between the Light and Dark Fae factions. This ongoing struggle between opposing forces adds an extra layer of suspense and intrigue to the show, ensuring that each season is packed with action, mystery, and high-stakes drama.

10. The Originals

urban fantasy tv shows

This gripping spinoff of The Vampire Diaries follows the Mikaelson family – the world’s first vampires – as they return to New Orleans to reclaim their power and face their demons. With five captivating seasons, The Originals delves deeper into the supernatural world, exploring themes of family, loyalty, and redemption. Rich in history and darkly atmospheric, this show will leave you longing for more blood-soaked drama and intrigue.

The Originals expands upon the rich world-building established in its parent show, offering a fresh perspective on the supernatural universe. The series dives headfirst into the complex relationships and power dynamics among vampires, werewolves, and witches in the vibrant city of New Orleans (also the setting of Poppy Z. Brite’s Lost Souls novel). By delving into the history of the Mikaelsons and the origins of their supernatural powers, The Originals provides viewers with an engrossing and multi-layered narrative that enriches the mythology of the Vampire Diaries universe.

One of the primary reasons The Originals is so binge-worthy lies in its compelling cast of characters. The Mikaelson siblings – Klaus (Joseph Morgan), Elijah (Daniel Gillies), and Rebekah (Claire Holt) – each possess distinct personalities, desires, and struggles that make them fascinating to watch. Their complex relationships and dysfunctional family dynamics form the emotional core of the series, ensuring that viewers remain invested in their journey toward redemption and power.

The show’s exploration of themes such as loyalty, family, and redemption also adds depth and nuance to the narrative. Throughout the series, the Mikaelsons are forced to confront their own demons and make difficult choices in order to protect their loved ones and secure their place in the supernatural world. This exploration of moral gray areas and the consequences of one’s actions elevates The Originals from a mere spinoff to a thought-provoking and compelling drama in its own right.

New Orleans serves as the perfect backdrop for The Originals, providing a rich and atmospheric setting that is steeped in history and culture. The city’s blend of French, Spanish, and African influences creates a unique and enchanting atmosphere that adds to the show’s darkly seductive charm. The vibrant jazz scene, intricate architecture, and lively celebrations like Mardi Gras serve as a visual feast for viewers, making the city itself an essential character in the series.

Finally, The Originals is known for its intense and high-stakes action sequences, which keep viewers on the edge of their seats. From epic battles between supernatural factions to nail-biting confrontations between the Mikaelsons and their enemies, the show never fails to deliver adrenaline-pumping excitement. This potent mix of action, drama, and intrigue ensures that viewers remain hooked from one episode to the next.

Embrace Your Dark Side and Binge On

binge watching tv shows

And there you have it! These ten wickedly addictive urban fantasy series offer the ultimate escape into worlds where the shadows harbor sinister secrets, and the heroes are deliciously flawed. So go on, surrender to your dark side, and binge to your heart’s content! After all, there’s no such thing as overindulging when it comes to enchanting tales of magic, myth, and delightfully murky morals.

Whether you’re bewitched by brooding vampires, howling at the moon with werewolves, or getting lost in the labyrinthine world of Fae politics, these shows promise to ensnare your imagination and keep you coming back for more.

So sit back, relax, and let these irresistible series work their magic on you. Trust us, once you start, you won’t be able to stop. Happy binging!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


red village ethan drake book 10
urban fantasy book cover design